The Great Pyramid: Did Maslow Get The Hierarchy Of Needs Right?
Maslow’s Pyramid of Human Needs Put to the Test
For more than 60 years, psychologist Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of human needs has served as a model by which many judge life satisfaction. But his theory has never been subjected to scientific validation.
A new global study tested Maslow’s concepts and sequence, in a way that reflects life in the 21st century.
“Anyone who has ever completed a psychology class has heard of Abraham Maslow and his theory of needs,” said University of Illinois professor emeritus of psychology Dr. Ed Diener, who led the study. “But the nagging question has always been: Where is the proof? Students learn the theory, but scientific research backing this theory is rarely mentioned.”
Maslow’s pyramid of human needs begins with a base that signifies an individual’s basic needs (for food, sleep and sex). Safety and security came next, then love and belonging, then esteem and, finally, at the pyramid’s peak, a quality he called “self-actualization.”
Maslow proposed that people who have these needs fulfilled should be happier than those who don’t.
In the new study, U of I researchers put Maslow’s ideas to the test with data from 123 countries representing every major region of the world.
To determine current perceptions, the researchers turned to the Gallup World Poll, which conducted surveys in 155 countries from 2005 to 2010, and included questions about money, food, shelter, safety, social support, feeling respected, being self-directed, having a sense of mastery, and the experience of positive or negative emotions.
The researchers found that fulfillment of a diversity of needs, as defined by Maslow, do appear to be universal and important to individual happiness. But the order in which “higher” and “lower” needs are met has little bearing on how much they contribute to life satisfaction and enjoyment, Diener said.
They also found that individuals identified life satisfaction (the way an individual ranked his or her life on a scale from worst to best) with fulfillment of basic life needs.
The satisfaction of higher needs – for social support, respect, autonomy or mastery – was “more strongly related to enjoying life, having more positive feelings and less negative feelings,” Diener said.
An important finding, Diener said, is that the research indicated that people have higher life evaluations when others in society also have their needs fulfilled.
“Thus life satisfaction is not just an individual affair, but depends substantially also on the quality of life of one’s fellow citizens,” he said.
“Our findings suggest that Maslow’s theory is largely correct. In cultures all over the world the fulfillment of his proposed needs correlates with happiness,” Diener said.
“However, an important departure from Maslow’s theory is that we found that a person can report having good social relationships and self-actualization even if their basic needs and safety needs are not completely fulfilled.”
- Researchers look for ingredients of happiness around the world (empressoftheglobaluniverse.wordpress.com)
- A Modified Maslow (Elizabeth Bryson Blog 9) (visualargument.wordpress.com)
July 5, 2011 - Posted by peterhbrown | Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, anxiety, Cognition, Identity, research, Resilience, Social Psychology, Spirituality | Abraham Maslow, Basic needs, Ed Diener, Life satisfaction, Maslow's hierarchy of needs, research, Self-actualization, University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
3 Comments »
Peter Brown BHMS (Hons) MPsychClin MAPS
I’m a Clinical Psychologist and have a private practice and consultancy in Brisbane Australia. I have 24 years experience in child, adult and family clinical psychology. I have a wonderful wife and three kids.
I am co-founder of Christian Wholeness Counselling Services.
I like researching issues of the brain & mind, reading and seeking out new books and resources for myself and my clients. I thought that others might be interested in some of what I have found also, hence this blog…
Join Me On FacebookPeter H Brown, Clinical Psychologist on Facebook
- 801,241 views
Search Peter’s Posts
- The bit of your brain that signals how bad things could be bit.ly/1lR5RA3 #depression 18 hours ago
- Scientists seeking way of detecting chronic traumatic encephalopathy in its earliest stages bit.ly/1nPdnj5 #depression 1 day ago
- Peer-led intervention helps mothers of children with autism bit.ly/1nuqNRo #depression 5 days ago
- Doctors achieve performance improvement in management of depression bit.ly/1nn4tJg #depression 6 days ago
- Impaired self-face recognition described in those with major depressive disorder bit.ly/1nqOGuA #depression 1 week ago
Popular TopicsAddiction Add new tag Adolescence aggression anxiety asd Aspergers Aspergers Syndrome Australia Autism Autism spectrum behavior book Books brain Bullying Canada CBT child Child Behavior children Cognition Communication contentment cyber depression diagnosis Disorders Education Exercise facebook Family Girls happiness Health Health Psychology Home Identity Internet kids learning lifestyle Love Major depressive disorder Marriage Mental disorder Mental health Mindfulness mood Parenting Parenting/Children personality Personality Disorder psychology relationship research Resilience Resources school self help self worth sex sexuality sleep Social Psychology Social Sciences stress Technology teen Temple Grandin therapy United States video Violence youth